After a car accident, you may know the other driver made a mistake, but you may also wonder if you could have done something differently.
Maybe you were going a little over the speed limit. Maybe you were distracted for a moment. Maybe you weren’t sure who had the right of way.
Does being partially at fault mean you can’t recover compensation?
Not necessarily.
South Carolina follows a system of comparative negligence, which means the amount of fault assigned to each person can affect whether and how much an injured person can recover.
What Is Comparative Negligence?
Comparative negligence recognizes that an accident can involve more than one person’s actions.
For example, imagine you’re involved in a crash and a jury determines that:
- The other driver was 80% at fault
- You were 20% at fault
- Your total damages were $100,000
If you are otherwise entitled to recover, your damages could be reduced by your percentage of fault. In this example, a 20% reduction would leave $80,000.
South Carolina’s Supreme Court has explained that a plaintiff may recover when their negligence is not greater than the defendant’s, with the recovery reduced in proportion to the plaintiff’s negligence.
That means being partially responsible for an accident does not automatically mean you walk away without a claim.
What If You Were 10%, 20%, or 30% at Fault?
Being assigned some percentage of fault can reduce your recovery, but it doesn’t necessarily prevent you from recovering altogether.
Using simple examples:
10% at fault:
If your damages were $50,000, a 10% reduction would leave $45,000.
30% at fault:
If your damages were $50,000, a 30% reduction would leave $35,000.
50% at fault:
South Carolina follows a “less than or equal to” comparative negligence approach. A plaintiff whose negligence is 50% or less may still recover, subject to the applicable rules, with damages reduced according to their percentage of fault.
The important point is that fault isn’t necessarily all-or-nothing.
What If You Were More Than 50% at Fault?
This is where the distinction becomes especially important.
Under South Carolina’s comparative negligence rule, a plaintiff generally cannot recover if their own negligence is greater than 50% of the total fault. South Carolina courts have repeatedly recognized this threshold.
So if you were found to be:
- 40% at fault: You may still recover, with your damages reduced by 40%.
- 50% at fault: You may still recover, with your damages reduced by 50%.
- 51% at fault: You generally cannot recover under South Carolina’s comparative negligence rule.
That’s why determining the actual percentage of fault can make such a significant difference in a car accident claim.
Who Decides How Much Fault You Have?
It’s not always as simple as one driver saying, “You caused the accident.”
Determining fault can involve looking at the circumstances surrounding the crash and the available evidence.
That may include:
- Police reports
- Photographs and videos
- Witness statements
- Vehicle damage
- Traffic signals and signs
- Road conditions
- Driver statements
- Accident reconstruction
- Other evidence showing how the collision occurred
South Carolina courts have recognized that when the evidence supports more than one reasonable interpretation of what happened, determining the parties’ respective percentages of negligence can be a question for the jury.
In other words, the fact that someone says you were partially responsible doesn’t automatically make it true.
What If the Other Driver Is Blaming You?
This is a situation many people find frustrating after a crash.
You may know what happened, but the other driver may tell their insurance company a different story. They might claim you were speeding, weren’t paying attention, failed to yield, or otherwise contributed to the collision.
Don’t assume that accusation settles the issue.
Evidence matters.
This is one reason it’s important to document the accident as thoroughly as possible and be careful about making statements to an insurance company before you understand what information is being used to evaluate fault.
You should always be truthful, but you don’t have to guess about things you don’t know.
What If Both Drivers Made Mistakes?
That’s exactly the type of situation comparative negligence is designed to address.
Consider a simple example:
You were making a left turn, and the other driver was traveling too fast. Both actions may have contributed to the crash.
Rather than automatically deciding that only one person was responsible, the circumstances can be evaluated to determine how much each person’s actions contributed to the accident.
South Carolina law provides for the apportionment of fault when multiple people or entities may have contributed to an injury.
The percentages can matter not only for determining whether you can recover, but also for determining how damages are allocated.
Don’t Assume a Small Mistake Means You Don’t Have a Case
This is important because people sometimes blame themselves after an accident.
You might think:
“I probably shouldn’t have been going that fast.”
Or:
“Maybe I should have seen the other car.”
Or:
“I know I wasn’t paying as much attention as I should have.”
Those thoughts don’t necessarily answer the legal question of who was responsible for the crash or what percentage of fault should be attributed to each person.
Car accidents can happen because of several contributing factors.
If you’ve been injured, it’s worth looking at the whole picture rather than deciding on your own that you don’t have a claim.
Talk With a South Carolina Car Accident Lawyer
Being partially at fault for an accident doesn’t automatically mean you have no legal options.
South Carolina’s comparative negligence rules recognize that responsibility for an accident can be shared. What matters is understanding what happened, what evidence supports each side, and how the law applies to your circumstances.
At Allen & Allen Law Firm, we help injured individuals and families throughout Anderson, Clemson, Pickens, Belton, Pendleton, Seneca, Abbeville, and communities across the Upstate understand their options after a car accident.
Contact Allen & Allen Law Firm to schedule a consultation about your South Carolina car accident.

